Free Feeding vs Scheduled Feeding

When deciding how to feed pets, owners typically choose between free feeding or scheduled feeding. Each approach has its pros and cons, and the choice often depends on the specific needs of the pet, lifestyle, and health considerations. Here's a breakdown of both feeding methods to help you determine what might work best for your pet.


Free Feeding

What Is Free Feeding?

Free feeding is when food is left out for pets to eat whenever they want. This works best with dry food, as wet food can spoil if left out for long periods.

Pros of Free Feeding

  1. Convenience: Owners don’t have to worry about sticking to specific feeding times, making it a flexible option.
  2. Less Stressful for Pets: Pets can eat whenever they’re hungry, which is especially beneficial for pets that self-regulate well.
  3. Helps Slow Eaters: Some pets are naturally slow eaters and might appreciate being able to eat throughout the day.

Cons of Free Feeding

  1. Potential Overeating: Many pets, particularly dogs, may overeat, leading to obesity and related health issues.
  2. Difficult to Track Intake: Owners may have trouble monitoring exactly how much food the pet is eating, which can be an issue if there are health concerns.
  3. Food Contamination: Food left out too long can become contaminated, attracting pests and losing freshness.
  4. Not Suitable for All Pets: Some pets, especially those with health conditions (e.g., diabetes), require specific, measured portions.

Scheduled Feeding

What Is Scheduled Feeding?

Scheduled feeding involves providing food at set times during the day. Typically, meals are portioned out according to the pet's size, age, and dietary needs.

Pros of Scheduled Feeding

  1. Better Portion Control: Owners can measure the exact amount of food, reducing the risk of overeating.
  2. Routine Establishment: Pets thrive on routines, and scheduled feeding helps them know when to expect meals.
  3. Behavioral Benefits: This method can be useful for training and behavior management, especially for pets that may become anxious or food-obsessed.
  4. Health Monitoring: It’s easier to observe changes in appetite, which can be an early sign of health issues.

Cons of Scheduled Feeding

  1. Time Commitment: Scheduled feeding requires owners to adhere to a specific routine, which can be challenging with a busy schedule.
  2. May Cause Hunger in Between Meals: Pets that require smaller, frequent meals might feel hungry between feedings, leading to begging or anxiety.
  3. Not Ideal for Grazing Eaters: Some pets, like certain cats, may prefer to eat smaller amounts throughout the day.

Which Option Is Best?

The choice depends on several factors:

  • Pet’s Age: Younger pets and kittens or puppies often benefit from scheduled feeding due to their higher energy needs and to establish healthy eating habits.
  • Health Needs: Pets with specific health conditions may need closely monitored, scheduled meals.
  • Lifestyle: Free feeding may suit busy owners, while scheduled feeding fits those who can commit to regular meal times.
  • Pet’s Personality: Some pets can self-regulate and do well with free feeding, while others may overeat or become anxious around food.

Combining Both Methods

Some pet owners use a hybrid approach, providing regular meals but leaving small amounts of food available throughout the day for pets who prefer grazing. Automated feeders can help manage portions for free-feeding pets or schedule meals if needed.


Ultimately, whether to free-feed or schedule-feed depends on the unique needs of both the pet and the owner. Consulting with a veterinarian can also offer guidance tailored to a pet’s individual needs and health status.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.